Showing posts with label alpina. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alpina. Show all posts

Sunday, February 10, 2019

NSOW 9-19 NOTES. ALPINA SEASTRONG DIVER 300

Please be aware these are just my notes for a VLOG, as such they will be a little sparse.  Please check out the VLOG 

ALPINA SEASTRONG DIVER 300
QUICK REVIEW

ALPINA PRESS RELEASE: https://alpinawatches.com/the-alpina-seastrong-diver-300-automatic/

----------------------------------------PTC--------------------------------------

IDENTITY
ALPINA SEASTRONG DIVER.  REF AL-525G4TS6
DIVE AND DAILY WEAR/ONE WATCH - REALLY A DIVE INSPIRED DTW
“THE DESIGN PRIVILEGES OPTIMAL DIVE TIME READABILITY AND STANDS OUT THROUGH ITS ESSENTIAL AND FUNCTIONAL BEAUTY, WHICH TRANSFORMS THIS TIMEPIECE IN A BEAUTIFUL MASCULINE OBJECT ALSO OUTSIDE THE WATER.”
ENTRY LEVEL SWISS

----------------------------------LB-------------------------------------

DESIGN
DIVER.  A CORE AIM AND GENERALLY THERE BUT SOME COMPROMISES.
WATER RESISTANCE - 300M PLENTY
UNIDIRECTIONAL BEZEL - GOT ONE
LEGIBILITY - SEE MINUTES ELAPSED AT A GLANCE
BIG FLAT DIAL AND CRYSTAL,
HIGH CONTRAST MARKERS - WHITE, NO FAUX PATINA
FURTHER EMPHASISED WITH POLISHED BOUNDARIES AND 3D EFFECT OF APPLIED MARKERS.
LONG MINUTE HAND
NO MINUTE MARKERS BETWEEN 5’S, DIAL OR BEZEL - A BIT VAGUE
OVERALL STURDY BUILD
PRETTY TOUGH. BANG ON. 316L STEEL CONSTRUCTION, SAPPHIRE CRYSTAL, SCREW DOWN CASE BACK AND CROWN GIVING 300M WATER RESISTANCE.
CROWN GUARD ARE THERE BUT MINIMAL FOR SYMMETRY

EVERYDAY: ALMOST PERFECT - ONLY QUESTION - TOO BIG?
WEARABILITY: 44MM/49MM/13MM. ROUND DIAL/BEZEL MOUNTED OVER A SQUARED OFF CUSHION MID-CASE GIVING THE WATCH “SHOULDERS” PLUS FURTHER MINIMAL SHOULDER PADS.  ALTOGETHER A VERY IMPOSING LOOK
BUT (LIKE MANY ALPINAS) SURPRISINGLY WEARABLE.
THIN (FOR A DIVER - SUB SAME THICKNESS) -
LOW SET AND
AGGRESSIVE ANGLED LUGS HELP
HOWEVER IN THE END IT’S STILL A 44MM AND MIGHT NOT FIT.

A LITTLE CLASS.
DEEP PERFECTLY MATT DIAL -
SIMPLE NO NONSENSE INDICES  -
EXCELLENT DATE INTEGRATION HIDES WHEN YOU DON'T WANT TO POPS WHEN YOU DO -
COHERENT (SHAPES AND COLORS  WORK TOGETHER AND SYMMETRY) AND PROPORTIONATE CASE - SUBTLE CASE SHAPING AND FINISHING.
WISE DECISION TO GO WITH ALUMINIUM BEVEL INSERT - DULL FINISH MAINTAINS OVERALL AESTHETIC OF DIAL
LESS PRINT ON DIAL WOULD BE GOOD THOUGH TO DOUBLE DOWN ON MINIMALIST AESTHETIC

A LITTLE FLARE.
ALL GOOD.
SILVERING OF NUMERALS AND INDICES
HINTS OF COLOUR IN ALPINA INSIGNIA
SMALL SHOULDER PADS TO AVOID SLAB SIDES
DELICATE CHAMFERS
MIX OF POLISHED AND SATIN FINISH
BLACK INSERT IN CROWN.
DISPLAY CASEBACK -
PLUS A BIT OF EFFORT GONE INTO DECORATING THE WORKMANLIKE MOVEMENT IN THE ENGINE BAY.

EXECUTION

MOVEMENT: AL525/SW 200 PERFECT CHOICE - SOLID/ACCURATE/SERVICEABLE
BAND: COMES WITH A REALLY NICE SOFT RUBBER BAND
PERFECTLY GOOD BUT I PREFER NATOS.
BUILD: CANT FAULT IT.
EVERYTHING CLEAN/NEAT/ALIGNED.
BEZEL ACTION LOVELY - SMOOTH BUT POSITIVE CLICK - NO PLAY
CROWN SCREW FEELS REALLY SMOOTH - BETTER THAN PILOT
BEZEL NOT OVERLY GRIPPY - SACRIFICED FOR LOOKS?
WOULD HAVE LOVED DRILLED LUGS
LUME - OVERALL PRETTY GOOD.

---------------------VOICE OVER-----------------------------

MARKETPLACE
PRICE:
MSRP:   1400USD
LIKELY:  700USD
ALTERNATIVES: LOTS - EVEN IF WE STICK TO SWISS
OBVIOUS:
ORIS AQUIS (1700/1200):
BETTER NAME, MORE DIVE FOCUSED, BUT INTEGRATED BAND/TWICE THE PRICE
NOT SO OBVIOUS:
HAMILTON KHAKI FROGMAN/CERTINA DS ACTION/LONGINES HYDROCONQUEST - ALL MORE DIVE/FUSSIER/LESS EVERYDAY
MIDO OCEAN STAR - VERY SIMILAR/BIT SMALLER/TITANIUM

--------------------------PTC------------------------------------------------------------

TAKE AWAY

ALPINA WERE REBORN AROUND 2002 WHEN TAKEN OVER BY FREDERIQUE CONSTANT AND THE FIRST YEARS WERE ROCKY - PROBLEM COULD BE SEEN IN THE NAME.  TRYING TOO HARD.
FOR ME - BIG GUY 19CM WRIST - THE ALPINA IS A BRILLIANT BLEND OF ITS TWO ROLES:
CLEARLY A DIVE WATCH BUT WITH LOTS OF LITTLE TWEEKS TO SEPARATE IT OUT OF THE CROWD AND GIVE IT REAL EVERYDAY ONE WATCH VERSATILITY.
ALPINA HAS FOUND A REALLY COOL TAKE ON THE DTW - THIS ONE DIVE INSPIRED (STARTIMER PILOT INSPIRED)
WELL EXECUTED AND LIKELY TO LAST A LIFETIME AND BE EASY TO SERVICE OVER THE JOURNEY.
ONLY REAL CONCERN IS SIZE.
HAVE TO COMMIT TO FORM OVER FUNCTION FOR DESIGN
COMPETITORS: STACKS UP REALLY WELL - COMPETITIVE ON DESIGN/EXECUTION/PRICE/ WITH EVERYTHING ELSE IN THIS SEGMENT. SERIOUS VALUE PROP.
HIGHLY RECOMMEND IF YOU NEED A REALLY MODERN DIVE INSPIRED DTW BUT ONE THAT IS STILL ACTUALLY A FULLY CAPABLE 300M DIVER.


Sunday, January 20, 2019

NSOW 4-19: ALPINA STARTIMER PILOT AUTO REVIEW

Note: this is barely a blog post. Actually these are my notes for a youtube video I've done reviewing this watch. See it at here.

ALPINA STARTIMER PILOT AUTO.  REF AL-525G4TS6
PILOT WATCH AND DAILY WEAR/ONE WATCH
ENTRY LEVEL SWISS

Roles

PILOT:

  • SUPREME LEGIBILITY - ACCURATE AT A GLANCE

EVERDAY:

  • WEARABILITY/A LITTLE CLASS/A LITTLE FLARE/A LITTLE TOUGH
Design
PILOT.  NAILS IT.
  • BIG FLAT DIAL AND CRYSTAL,
  • HUGE HIGH CONTRAST MARKERS, CLEAR MINUTE TRACK
  • FURTHER EMPHASISED WITH POLISHED BOUNDARIES AND 3D EFFECT OF APPLIED MARKERS.
  • LONG, HIGHLY VISIBLE BUT ALSO THIN HANDS.
  • HUGE, EASY TO USE CROWN



EVERDAY: ALMOST PERFECT - TOO BIG?


  • WEARABILITY: 44MM/52MM/10MM. IMPOSING LOOK - BUT (LIKE MANY ALPINAS) SURPRISINGLY WEARABLE. THIN.
    • LOW SET AND AGGRESSIVE CURVED LUGS HELP BUT IN THE END ITS BIG AND MIGHT NOT FIT.
  • A LITTLE CLASS. DEEP BLUE/GREY DIAL - SIMPLE FONTS - EXCELLENT DATE INTEGRATION - COHERENT AND PROPORTIONATE CASE - SUBTLE CASE SHAPING AND FINISHING CLEARLY ELEVATE FROM THE COCKPIT.
    • LESS PRINT ON DIAL WOULD BE GOOD THOUGH.
    • NICE CASEBACK BUT DISPLAY MIGHT HAVE WORKED BETTER.
    • 21MM LUG SPACING NOT IDEAL.
  • A LITTLE FLARE. ALL GOOD. SILVERING OF NUMERALS AND INDICES - HINTS OF COLOUR IN ALPINA INSIGNIA - TOUCHES OF POLISH AND SLIGHT BEVELLING.
  • A LITTLE TOUGH. BANG ON. 316L STEEL CONSTRUCTION, SAPPHIRE CRYSTAL, SCREW DOWN CASE BACK AND CROWN GIVING 100M WATER RESISTANCE. NOT TOO SOFT - NOT TOO HARD - JUST RIGHT.


EXECUTION
MOVEMENT: AL525/SW 200 PERFECT CHOICE.
BAND: SIMPLE BLACK SUEDE BAND WHITE STITCHING.
  • NICE - I PREFER NATOS. 
BUILD: CANT FAULT IT.
  • EVERYTHING CLEAN/NEAT/ALIGNED.
  • CROWN SCREW FEELS A LITTLE ROUGH
  • WOULD HAVE LOVED DRILLED LUGS
MARKETPLACE
PRICE:
  • MSRP:   1050USD
  • LIKELY:  650USD (LOW AS 500)
ALTERNATIVES:
  • OBVIOUS: ORIS BIG CROWN PRO PILOT (1700/1200): BETTER NAME, SIMPLER, MORE TOOLY, SMALLER at 41MM, TWICE THE PRICE
  • NOT SO OBVIOUS: 
    • FORTIS. SPACEMATIC/COCKPIT/FLIEGER - Lots of options, best alternatives.
    • LACO/STOWA - More flieger, less versatile, more expensive
    • HAMILTON KHAKI PILOT - More flieger, less versatile, less dressy
    • SINN 556 - 1100USD - More tooly less piloty, far more expensive
TAKE AWAY
ROLE SATISFACTION:

  • FOR ME - BIG GUY WITH 19CM WRIST - THE ALPINA IS A BRILLIANT BLEND OF ITS TWO ROLES.  CLEARLY A PILOT WATCH BUT WITH LOTS OF LITTLE TWEEKS TO LIFT IT OUT OF THE FLIEGER CROWD AND GIVE IT REAL EVERYDAY ONE WATCH VERSATILITY.
  • WELL EXECUTED AND LIKELY TO LAST A LIFETIME AND BE EASY TO SERVICE OVER THE JOURNEY.
  • ONLY REAL CONCERN IS SIZE.

COMPETITORS:

  • STACKS UP REALLY WELL - COMPETITIVE ON DESIGN/EXECUTION/PRICE/ WITH EVERYTHING ELSE IN THIS SEGMENT. SERIOUS VALUE PROPOSITION